Open Letter to the MyQ Community

  • 7
  • Problem
  • Updated 2 years ago
To the MyQ Community:

Hello! I’d like to introduce myself. My name is Kylie and I work directly for Chamberlain’s marketing and product teams where safety, security, product quality, and customers are our top priorities. The former community Manager is no longer with our company and I will help communicate with the MyQ Community moving forward.

I’ve taken time to review the questions and comments that have been posted over the past few months. Thank you so much for your feedback, ideas and, yes, even constructive criticism. The Community was developed to have open discussions around the topics that matter most to all of you. To make sure that your feedback is heard, I will be compiling your ideas and suggestions into a monthly report for our management team to review. We believe that our customers have some really awesome ideas and we want to make sure that they are given the attention they deserve.

Going in and out of the garage is often an afterthought for the average person, but at Chamberlain, we don’t see it that way. Your garage is where you keep your car, where you store your prized possessions, where your family members and pets enter and exit the home multiple times a day, every day. It’s the gateway to everything that matters most to you.

Our mission is to bring you an awesome MyQ experience, and so safety, security, product quality and customer experience drive all of our product decisions. That’s true for all our products, including MyQ. We also realize, however, that many feel frustrated that we haven’t provided a firm date regarding several of our products and partnership integrations.

Here’s why. The products we develop must work in an environment that is complex, ever-changing, and -- frankly -- not always under our control. Third parties (like automobile companies, smart phone manufacturers and others) have their own standards and we often need to accommodate them all or develop new technological adaptations. With all that going on, it's difficult to provide firm dates because there's so much development that goes into our products. The industry’s changing landscape drives the extensive amount of QA testing that we put our products through. New opportunities and challenges are presented every day. We evaluate and address every issue we can identify before releasing our products to market. Our customers are our top priority, so we feel that protecting a major access point (the garage) to their home requires that type of scrutiny and attention to detail.

We always work hard to stay on track with our product schedules, but  Chamberlain, like any company that really cares about its customers, is willing to adjust a deadline to ensure your and your families’ safety and security.  We balance the importance of releasing top-of-the-line technology with your overall experience. 

I’d like to ask and thank you for your patience while we work hard to develop our products. I personally assure you the moment I can provide dates for any product updates and partner integrations, I will let the MyQ Community know. 


Thank you,

Kylie 

The MyQ Team

Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes

Posted 3 years ago

  • 7
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Thanks for the update but it totally sidesteps the clearly articulated concerns from many of us. Specifically, what products will be updated to support HomeKit as promised? Will it simply be a firmware update as promised? Will some require new or additional hardware? If so, what will chamberlain do to accommodate customers who purchased based on promises made by chamberlain?

None of this requires a firm date. But I do think a quarter wouldn't be outrageous to provide. If you can't estimate within a quarter after a year of stalling then I would suggest better product managers and developers.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
I understand why you are frustrated. I’ll be able to provide a list of products when our development and QA testing is complete. 

I'm going to add your comments to my report and I will ask our teams to let me know the moment new information is available so I can share it with you and the community. 

Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
I'm not sure you do understand why I (and we) are frustrated. It's been a YEAR since this was promised. Multiple times since it's been promised. Now Chamberlain won't even confirm which products or what the upgrade process will be (firmware, new hardware, etc). Something has gone terribly wrong clearly.

Yes, technology changes quickly. Yet dozens upon dozens of other companies are sticking to their promises with things like HomeKit integration. Quite frankly, Chamberlain is much larger than they are but clearly anything more than a basic motor and chain is beyond your technical capabilities.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Fair enough. Honestly at times, I feel frustrated too because I want to share every detail with community here. While I can't share details (as much as it pains me, sincerely!) I can tell you that extensive development and QA testing are necessary to make sure we give you the safest, securest, top-notch smart-control product possible. 
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
That's a boilerplate non-response. Are you suggesting adding HomeKit in some way would make your product unsafe or not secure? That's nonsense. 

Does the MyQ have the necessary hardware required for HomeKit, yes or no?
Photo of Jim Chase

Jim Chase

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
August lock had to release a new version of their smart lock in order to add HomeKit integration to their product. Apple required some sort of additional security chip be added to support HomeKit. I suspect MyQ garage does not have this chip in the current design.
Photo of tsteele93

tsteele93

  • 15 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
What I find frustrating is how they absolve themselves of any responsibility for missing (oops, I mean "adjusting") deadlines because it is the fault of someone else. That's the kind of attitude that ensures that the customer is not gonna get a straight answer.

Instead of, "We screwed up, we missed our deadlines that we promised" it is someone else's fault and we are all a bunch of ignorant fools who don't realize our garage is - OMG! - an entrance to our homes! "And I bet you guys didn't know you kept stuff that was valuable to you in there either! Because all you thought about was opening and closing that big ole door! You big dummies. Now hush up, we'll get to it when we get to it. And quit complaining because you thought we were gonna get to it when we said we would get to it, because: 'danger!'"
(Edited)
Photo of Eli H Robinson

Eli H Robinson

  • 3 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
I'll start by stating that I'm a software engineer, and I work closely with a certain Amazon voice software. (You can take that as you wish).

Now, it pains me to see people frustrated when it comes to cool features. I'd like to state however, that it's not always "so easy" to get cool stuff like this to simply work. Companies as large as Chamberlain MUST cover their legal behinds. Because we are the same people who would turn around and sue, if someone robbed us because Chamberlain released some new software which wasn't as close to perfect as possible.

I've spent a great deal of time researching various garage doors and openers and the world of connectivity between them. I, as much as you all, want to be able to have my garage door magically open whenever I need it to. However, I also know, through my own software I've written, how easy it is to accidentally miss something, and come home to a garage door which has been opening and closing itself (luckily it was closing itself every 2 minutes due to my auto-close setting, thank goodness for that feature from Chamberlain) for 2 hours straight. Turning on and off lights in our house, or the thermostat, or watching our home camera system, is relatively safe compare to the entrance to your home being completely open or not.

Now I ask you all to consider this statement before you post another "WTF, hurry the heck up" comment. Would you leave a door unlocked when you left your house? If the answer is yes, why not just lock the garage door open? For most of us, the answer is no, and because of this, we really should give it the time necessary to test things right.

But what do I know, I only write software for a living right? :)
Photo of Trevor B.

Trevor B.

  • 44 Posts
  • 6 Reply Likes
Thank you and Welcome Kylie!

I understand we work in a complex environment when it comes to integration and working with third parties, so we can have some understanding there, but the amount of time and false promises has long buried any understanding and we can only assume there is a problem along the way that is not getting the attention it deserves, hopefully with you here that can change.

Another thing that frustrates your customers, is things that you can control yet completely ignore. We understand integrations are dependent on other parties. But what about building a simple timer or scheduling feature into your existing MyQ app? IMO Chamberlain has no one to blame but themselves about that. Having MyQ light switches without these features are almost useless without them and prevents users from upgrading their MyQ system. Adding those simple features to the MyQ app would have increase sales of those MyQ products.

Looking forward to your updates, hopefully in the near future.
Photo of Scott Weidig

Scott Weidig

  • 120 Posts
  • 21 Reply Likes
Completely agree with the above two posts. That said, I know that many of us are more than willing to give you the benefit of the doubt, especially taking over here. A number of us are very active in the community helping out and having a dedicated and active community manager will be a step in the right direction. "Chamberlain, like any company really cares about its customers..." Is something that many will feel that we are not and have not been seeing.

Welcome to the community, and we hope that you can provide some information on the question all of us have been posting about: HomeKit integration.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi Trevor, 

Do you have a wall control panel in your garage? It comes with most of our openers and it has a timer to close function. If you go into the MyQ app and indicate that you want to be notified of any changes to your garage door state, it'll let you know that the garage door has been shut via control panel function. 

With that said, I recognize that you want to set that timer through the app, not the control panel so I'll be sure to add that to the list of requests to pass on to our team. 

To make sure I'm understanding how you'd like to use our MyQ Lighting Control, are you saying that you want the lights to turn off when the timer function closes the door? If so, I pass that information on to our development team. 

To the best of my knowledge, right now the MyQ Lighting can be controlled through the app as long as it's linked to a MyQ Garage, Gateway device or a Wi-Fi Garage Door Opener but it currently doesn't link with the timer to close function.  

Kylie
Photo of Trevor B.

Trevor B.

  • 44 Posts
  • 6 Reply Likes
Hi Kylie, 

Yes, I have the control panel in the garage, I had to by it because the app doesn't have a timer function that would close the garage door after being open for X minutes. The notifications are okay, but a pain because I don't want to know about every open and close event.

For the MyQ lights, no I don't want it to have anything to do with the lights. I would like a scheduler function to turn the lights on at 8pm and off at 11pm. Also a timer function for the lights so that if they are turned on, they automatically turn off after X period of time.

Yes the MyQ lights can be controlled via the app but IMO it is just a "dumb" light switch, it has no smarts to it. If it could automatically turn the lights on a dusk and off at dawn that would be cool too. Even cooler, if it could turn on my selected light automatically when I open the garage door only if it's after dusk, then turn off after X period of time that would be even smarter.

The current sync feature for lights where it turns them on/off all the time with the garage door opener light doesn't make sense, I don't want all my exterior lights for example to turn on when I open the garage during the day, that would be pointless to have them do that.

Even smarter, have the app automatically open the garage door as my smartphone senses I am returning home (Geo fence). Other home automation systems do this.

Now imagine all of that with IFTTT integration where we can set events and triggers for all of our connected smart devices, then everyone would want your products. This is the direction the world is going in. Either catch up, or get left behind.....

Sorry for all of us bombarding you, but as you can see there is a lot of pent up need.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi Trevor,

This is excellent and really detailed feedback that I can pass on to my team. Your comment explains that situations that would that would call for specific functions in the app. I can't promise anything, but this is really good insight for us to look further into.  

Thanks! 

Kylie
Photo of tsteele93

tsteele93

  • 15 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Kylie, if you need for us to tell you what real world situations would call for those specific functions in the app, then your team has some serious problems.

Perhaps you guys need to read about the Edsel. It's a fascinating story. The short version is that Ford Motor Company decided to build a car based on what customer said they really wanted. And guess what , no one really wanted it.

That's why successful companies are able to determine what customers want even when the customer doesn't already know. Successful companies are able to create things people didn't know they wanted. Successful companies don't sit around and wait for the customer to demand stuff that should've already been included in the product.

At the very best-case scenario, that is playing catch up. You will get steamrolled by a company that comes in and creates a product that does things that we didn't even know we wanted to do or needed to do. And meanwhile Chamberlain is still trying to integrate things that customers are begging for them to integrate. for over a year. That's just sad.

I'm sure that you really love reading our comments. I have worked for large corporations where it was frustrating to watch the lawyers drag the products down into mediocrity or worse. I see you begin almost every comment about safety. And yes we get it, safety is important because whether you care about us or not, you do care about liability lawsuits. We understand that.

But we already have a great deal of safety built into garage door systems now. None of us are asking for those to be thrown out. We are not asking you to disable safety. All were asking for is to be able to control the garage door the way we want to control it. The safety features are automatic it already built in and should ALREADY cover any scenario we might come up with. If they don't, then be honest with us and tell us what you feel like that is not safe for us to do some of the things we want to do. We would have a great deal more respect for you if you did that, then it whenever you vaguely spout off things about safety while it appears to us that the product already has safety built in. Garage door openers have endured years of litigation and have been refined to the point where we assume that you already are making a safe product. How we activate that product should not make it any more or less dangerous. Your product should already be safe and our method of activating it shouldn't change that.

I'm not going to put you on the spot and ask you any hard questions. I'm just going to let you know that if Chamberlain is sitting around trying to figure out what we need based on this forum and then trying to play catch up by tryIng to implement those things a year or longer after they've been asked for then you should seriously be looking for a better place to work. Because Chamberlain won't be doing this that much longer. Some upstart company or kick starter campaign he will come along and clean their clocks.

Tom Steele
http://www.hawkandtom.com
Photo of Tom Carroll

Tom Carroll

  • 6 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Kylie, the feature to set a programmed time to close (so the open door isn't forgotten about and left open all night) whether in the myQ app or via the wall panel would be a great feature.  I for one bought the Chamberlain door opener because of the myQ technology and what I thought would be a well developed and feature full system.  I have been severely disappointed.
Photo of Jon McCullough

Jon McCullough

  • 20 Posts
  • 6 Reply Likes
I'm pleased to see some type of response from the MyQ team!  While anxious, I also understand the ever changing technology landscape.  If you ever require a technical mind for evaluation and beta purposes I volunteer myself as tribute to provide well evaluated analysis of the MyQ technology. I look forward to updates that improve the experience for myself and others!
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
We will definitely take that offer into consideration. New technology always needs beta testers, especially one's that are tech savvy.

Do you know any other community members who would be open to being a beta tester? Can't say for what product but it's always good to have a list ready if the opportunity presents itself. Maybe I should start another post around that idea?
Photo of Ethan

Ethan

  • 7 Posts
  • 11 Reply Likes
I'd definitely be interested in being a beta tester, Kylie.

Thanks again for the updates.
Photo of Jon McCullough

Jon McCullough

  • 20 Posts
  • 6 Reply Likes
There are a few technically minded folks in the previous thread who have created or implemented solutions who would be of peak interest since they already communicated solutions on integrating the Chamberlain garage both open and closed based on commands.

I wrote a few and found it fun; I enjoy making my technology work as simply as a toaster: pop down bread, wait 30 seconds, then enjoy nice tasty toast.
Photo of Jose B Olagues

Jose B Olagues

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
I would be interested in being a tester.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Cool. I've added both of your names to the list. I think I'll have to comb the other threads to see if others have mentioned becoming a possible beta testers.
 
Photo of Michael Maulucci

Michael Maulucci

  • 13 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
I'd also be interest in beta testing
Photo of Phillip Driscoll

Phillip Driscoll

  • 2 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Sign me up for beta testing too!
Photo of Richard Cueto

Richard Cueto

  • 3 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
Me 3...
Photo of Scott Weidig

Scott Weidig

  • 120 Posts
  • 21 Reply Likes
I would be interested as well.
Photo of Jeff DeWolfe

Jeff DeWolfe

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
I am interested in Beta testing too.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
You all already are Beta testers, : ) :) 
Photo of Nate Greene

Nate Greene

  • 3 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
I would be interested in Beta Testing.
Photo of Patrick Gormley

Patrick Gormley

  • 5 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I'am in!
Photo of Eric Anderson

Eric Anderson

  • 2 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
I would be interested in beta testing as well. I have a lot of experience beta testing software.
Photo of Ward

Ward

  • 2 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
This is a very long beta test for a system as simple as a garage door opener!
Photo of Noah Archer

Noah Archer

  • 19 Posts
  • 5 Reply Likes
@Kylie, Βeta testing would actually require testing the integration between MyQ and HomeKit and unless we've all missed something here, there isn't any integration available to beta test or otherwise. Are you saying that MyQ isn't even a stable release yet?
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Kylie, Here are excepts from a message that I sent to Cory Sorice on February 17, 2016:
I’d like to be part of the solution rather than part of the confusion. Perhaps I can help in two ways: technical feedback and messaging.

Regarding technical feedback, there are several highly technical people who are part of the MyQCommunity site as you can see if they are setting up HomeBridge on a Raspberry Pi. Maybe you can harness several of them, including myself, to beta or field test upcoming enhancements for HomeKit. Screen us with an interest survey that includes questions about what other SmartHome and IoT devices we use. If necessary, have us digitally sign a non-disclosure and set up a private site for us to provide technical and user experience feedback on using MyQ Garage and other Chamberlain products on iOS with and without HomeKit.

Regarding messaging, the online community is very frustrated right now with vagueness of the official statements (see below) and feeling like they have been misled over the past year regarding an upcoming firmware update. You can see that in three HomeKit threads on the MyQCommunity site.

Honesty and transparency would be a wise move right now based upon how the community is responding, especially after being promised HomeKit support. Are you targeting the next month, 3 months, 6 months, or even 9 months. Which select products it work with? Will new hardware be necessary? Without some sort of time frame and specifics, the official statements lead to speculation.

I'd also recommend that Chamberlain to come clean on their Twitter feed, community support site, and their sales web site about the technical and engineering difficulties that the team has had trying to add HomeKit support. Perhaps then Chamberlain can begin to regain the trust from the SmartHome community. We have seen others like Philips and Ecobee transition in new products to support HomeKit but neither had specifically promised that the earlier product would be compatible via a firmware update.

If it turns out that new hardware is needed for HomeKit support, I trust that Chamberlain will do the right thing and offer a free HomeKit upgrade for those who bought in 2015 because HomeKit support was assured.

Please let me know how I can best help.

Chamberlain Official Statements on HomeKit
"Chamberlain is a HomeKit partner. We are reviewing our product plans for HomeKit integration. Select Chamberlain MyQ-enabled products will support HomeKit. This includes specific Chamberlain Wi-Fi Garage Door Openers with Smartphone Control and a HomeKit version of Chamberlain MyQ Garage."
AND
"Chamberlain is a HomeKit partner. Select Chamberlain MyQ-enabled products will support HomeKit but can’t share specific timing."
I hope your open letter today is the first step of a new messaging strategy for the MyQ team; one that brings honesty and transparency to your customers who can either be your biggest fans or most terrible foes.

Respectfully,
Jeffrey
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Let me add that based upon the competitive landscape for SmartHome products, the MyQ team should focus first on IFTTT support, then Apple HomeKit, then Amazon Alexa.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi Jeffrey, 

That was a well written and thoughtful letter it shows how much you care. I'm glad that we have such passionate and concerned customers like yourself. Please Let me touch base with my teams. I'm just as excited to see what happens with HomeKit. I promise I will tell you and community any information that I can as soon as I can. 
(Edited)
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Thanks Kylie! It seems that things are already moving in a better, more positive direction.
Photo of HarrySamuel

HarrySamuel

  • 94 Posts
  • 40 Reply Likes
Yes, my VeraPlus is installed, and I paired the first wall receptacle, much easier than I expected. I can turn it off and on from anywhere it the world, now to setup timers, and install more. Then to rip out the Chamberlain MyQ controller, well maybe keep a couple as those do not need timers, but they will be a negative to a working system. Yes Things ARE getting better !!! : )
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
HarrySamuel,

It sounds like you are most concerned with lighting controls and not really the MyQ Garage solution. I hope VeraPlus works for you. Your needs are different than most from the other thread who are waiting for HomeKit support so we can ask Siri to open or close our garage doors.

For lighting controls, I've been using the iHome iSP5 Smart Plug and Lutron Caseta. The iHome iSP5 is compatible with HomeKit, Nest, Wink, Alexa, and IFTTT. It was on sale at Home Depot for $25 and was up and running with timers in 15 minutes. The Lutron Caseta is similarly compatible and offers dimming functions but was more expensive.

Best,
Jeffrey
Photo of HarrySamuel

HarrySamuel

  • 94 Posts
  • 40 Reply Likes
Does it work with the MyQ light switch controls I already have installed ?
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
I don't think so. I'm not as familiar with those. Are your existing MyQ light switch controls working with your new setup?
Photo of HarrySamuel

HarrySamuel

  • 94 Posts
  • 40 Reply Likes
No, Chamberlain has a closed system, and have no real plans to add any IFTTT or integration with any other system. Really sad, as when I spoke to them they say its coming. I really wish I had gone with something else. Not sure if I will change everything out, or just run two systems.
(Edited)
Photo of tsteele93

tsteele93

  • 15 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Jeffrey, I'm gonna go out on a limb and wonder if Chamberlain has any plans whatsoever to allow us to ask Siri to open the garage door. I'm betting it won't happen. I might be wrong, but they just shut down access to this function via Amazon Echo (Alexa.)

They asked SmartThings to quit allowing a customer written code to do that because it was using an undocumented API feature or something to that effect. You can read about it on the smart things forum.

If they don't want us opening and closing our garage door from Alexa, I'm doubtful their lawyers want us to open and close it from our smartphones via voice either...

What confuses me, is that even though Chamberlain's open letter seems like they think we are all a bunch of idiots who had no idea that there are security aspects to opening and closing garage doors and also physical dangers, our garage doors already have sensors that do not allow them to close if they are obstructed and reverse if they encounter resistance, so why is that an issue?

Or do those features not actually assure safe operation now and they depend on visual sight to ensure that they do not harm someone?
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
http://www.smarthomehub.net/forums/discussion/519/myq-garage-to-be-homekit-compatible-with-just-a-fi...

Promised to deliver last year as a firmware upgrade. This update isn't enough.
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
https://www.broadcom.com/press/release.php?id=s809321

Broadcom's WICED Platform Powers Chamberlain MyQ Garage

http://www.broadcom.com/blog/wireless-technology/wiced-now-supports-homekit/

So it seems that maybe it does have the proper hardware to support HomeKit, but the silence is deafening. 
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi Mr. Cow (no user name),

I wish I could provide details at this time but I'm not able to. I am listening and I understand the foundation of all of your frustrations. I have shared your comments and questions with our management team. Aside from the question that I'm unable to answer, may I help you with anything else? We care about our customers and I will answer what I can. 
(Edited)
Photo of HarrySamuel

HarrySamuel

  • 94 Posts
  • 41 Reply Likes
So to cut ALL the writing short, it does not work, and may or may not work in 100 years, maybe sooner. That's the short answer.
Photo of tsteele93

tsteele93

  • 15 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
To be fair, Kylie is being honest with you. She is not allowed to answer your question. Why beat her up? The real short answer is that Chamberlain is choosing not to tell us what they are doing. Many companies do that. Most of them don't send a sacrificial lamb into their forums to be their lightning rod of hate. Lol.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
To be fair, Kylie's bosses are doing NOTHING, so she can not tell you something is happening when it is not. Wish I knew how bad this company is. The Smartthing community www.community.smartthings.com loves Chamberlain like I do. Chamberlain just shut them down saying their servers could not handle the traffic. I guess they never replaced that XT they are using.
Photo of Eli H Robinson

Eli H Robinson

  • 3 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
After doing some basic integration with Apple's HomeKit, the API for HomeKit isn't the best... Perhaps this is the problem? Perhaps they are working on a brand new public facing API which would allow integration onto MANY platforms. Software doesn't write itself, and it definitely doesn't get written, well, overnight.
Photo of Chip Cox

Chip Cox

  • 14 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
The issue with this is really with integration to Apple's HomeKit, Chamberlain being a little to optimistic about their statement it their openers were compatible with HomeKit, and some people who had rather complain than find a working solution.  News flash everything does not always work as advertised.  Get over it and if you want the functionality, try something else (Wink hubs work great in my house with my Liftmaster garage door opener).  
Photo of Mike Lemay

Mike Lemay

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
Hello Kylie and Good Day.  

I have a question that many have posted on here in the past and recently.  

Is Chamberlain going to make the change of allowing more than one login to the gateway?  This seems pretty basic and in this day and age with security being paramount, sharing lD's and Passwords seems a bit ridiculous.....and a security issue for the user/owner.

Thoughts?
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi Mike, we've heard  similar requests from customers like you. While I can't give specifics, I can say that we've been working on a really cool road map for where we want to take the MyQ app. 

But with that said, I'll add your request to my report to reiterate to management how important that feature is to our customers. I'm happy bother a few people here to make sure that conversation stays active. :)
Photo of Eric Anderson

Eric Anderson

  • 2 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
I too would like the ability to add guest accounts. I have guests come over often, and I would like them to allow themselves in, but only have that permission at certain times of the day, or on certain specified days.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Thanks for the feedback, Eric. I'll pass that comment along. :)
Photo of Richard Cueto

Richard Cueto

  • 3 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
Amazes me that a company ignores an issue hoping the problem will go away, and instead the customers do....
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi Richard, 
We understand why our customers are frustrated and it pains me to not be able to provide exact details. With that said, I promise you that we recognize that this issue exists and we won't let it go away. We're actively working on our HomeKit integration. Once our development and QA testing is finished, we'll be able to provide answers that our customers have been asking for. 
Photo of HarrySamuel

HarrySamuel

  • 94 Posts
  • 40 Reply Likes
I waited, now I wait for my VeraPlus to be delivered, in a few days, if the USPS is being honest. 
Photo of Michael Maulucci

Michael Maulucci

  • 13 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Honestly I don't think people understand working relationships and confidentiality between companies, specially Apple! What Kylie has stated is all chamberlain can say due to these rules. They are not trying to hide or not deliver. You can clearly see that in the way the letter was written. I would love himekit support, and I bought my opener with that in mind. But it works great every other way, and when the time is right, they will release more info. Thank you Kylie and Chamberlain for addressing this and putting someone on it to respond with the best of their ability.
Photo of HarrySamuel

HarrySamuel

  • 94 Posts
  • 41 Reply Likes
Your kidding right ??? This has ddrraaggggeeeedddd on way to long. To market something as Homekit when it clearly is not is fraud. 
Photo of Ivan Karpenko

Ivan Karpenko

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
It has been a year and a half since Chamberlain promised this feature. I regret buying the MyQ and wish I would have gotten one of their competitor's products instead.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
Ok, Chamberlain said Homekit will work, all I wanted was a little control, more than Chamberlain gives. Homekit, Echo, it is all actually working, and probably breaking more laws then I can imagine. Apple is scum, all they want is money. Chamberlain does not have the management to do business with Apple. For Apple is scum, and how can you do business with scum. I blamed Chamberlain for a long time, but the more research I did, I found Apple is the problem, and Chamberlain has been taking the blame, I guess not wanting to anger the great big Apple. Chamberlain has not opened up there system, so Smartthings is down. So much blame to go around and the customer is the loser. I can only say I went to z-wave, and am happy I did.All I wanted I have, or will have with a few more sensors. It is a shame Apple is the wrong choice, and Chamberlain is not as bad, but not good. Stick with local control inside your network, z-wave does that, and you can hack in what you want, but maybe just stay away from the companies that want to control your system. Only go with products that allow you to control your system, like my system now does. NO DISTANT SERVER CONTROLLING YOUR SWITCHES !!! VeraPlus allows local control, and if you know a little you can control from anywhere, and they do have free servers if you are not up to speed yet. VeraPlus is the best there is, period
Photo of Ethan

Ethan

  • 7 Posts
  • 11 Reply Likes
As an Apple developer dating back to Mac Desktop OS 9.6, I'm well aware of NDA's and the difficulties of maintaining a working relationship with Apple. Chamberlain has misinformed it's users in the past with certain info they can no longer talk about. That's fine.

That said, I made a reasonable decision to buy their product based off their direct communication. The device is nice, but thats not the issue. The company still has the ability and responsibility to inform it's customer base that they will make the issue correct in the future at no additional cost due to their mistake.

No public mention of a future roadmap is needed here. I've waited. I want to know I will get value back on my investment in a way in the future that will not cost me extra money?

I do not blame Kylie. I blame management. I've asked a question. Chamberlain can't answer it due to future roadmaps and Apple. Fine.

I've now rephrased a  pointed question, which cannot be reframed and can be answered directly without divulging sensitive information they cannot release.

I'm still patiently waiting for a response, Kylie. Hope to hear from you soon.
(Edited)
Photo of Chip Cox

Chip Cox

  • 14 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
I don't know what happened with Chamberlain and Apple.  But I do know your question cannot be answered until Chamberlain knows what the final solution is going to be.  Also, knowing technology like you do as an Apple developer, you know that no fix is ever really free especially when it comes to hardware.  There is always a new power supply, printer driver, interface cable or something that inevitably has to be purchased.  Why would this be any different.  
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
I'm guessing it's that pesky printer driver that's caused a two year delay.
(Edited)
Photo of Chip Cox

Chip Cox

  • 14 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
based on what they are saying, it could be.  :)  But you get my point.  There is always a cost to technology.  Even when they say there isn't there is.  It's just the reality of things.  I've done my share of development for the past 30 years.  I've gone through the DOS to windows 3.1 to Windows 95, to XP and so on conversions.  There is always a cost.  :)
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Perhaps they shouldn't have promised it two years ago if it wasn't ready. I don't think it's unreasonable to expect them to ship a promised feature in that's period of time.
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Also, the cost is inevitable, of course. But they knew that cost presumably before they announced the shipping date of the feature (June of 2015). The VP himself announced it. Now he refuses to address the issue. Rather they have radio silence.
Photo of Chip Cox

Chip Cox

  • 14 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
The radio silence is bad from a customer relationship perspective.  I'll give you that.  But what happened between the time they shipped the first devices and now.  That's what we don't know.  Has Apple changed the requirements on development for HomeKit?  Have the HomeKit API's changed in some way that makes HomeKit unsafe (in Chamberlin's legal teams eyes) to use it that way?  Have there been hacking instances with HomeKit that make Chamberlain worry of opening their system up to it?  I have no idea to the answer to those questions.  So as a developer, I know that sometimes requirements change or API's change that impact other applications. I agree that Chamberlain has handled this poorly from a customer relations perspective.  But I would not be surprised if there were a cost associated with a fix, especially considering how long this has been and how many revisions to HomeKit there have probably been since then.
Apparently Chamberlain was an early HomeKit adopter.  Maybe they developed based on a beta release and the production version was different somehow.  Yes bad management, I agree.  But I can understand it, it's not unusual for early adopters to get burned.
(Edited)
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Perhaps they shouldn't have allowed Apple to promote them as a HomeKit partner (that has never shipped a product) as recently as October if they were unable to deliver on their promises. They were happy to take the free press for two years, since CES of 2015, multiple Apple events where they got stage time, press releases, interviews, stage time with other HomeKit partners. But somehow there's an unforeseen cost. I don't buy it. Not for two years.

I say this as a software product manager in a highly regulated industry. "Real artists ship." I ship.
Photo of Chip Cox

Chip Cox

  • 14 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
I agree.  Chamberlain has handled this poorly.  Maybe the problem is that their industry isn't as highly regulated as yours (and mine).  This product would never have shipped if it had to undergo the same type testing that the financial and medical worlds have to undergo.
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
It would also be illegal to make forward looking statements as they have if they were publicly traded.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi Ethan,

I understand you are looking for an answer to that question today and we have to ask for your patience and understanding just a little while longer. It's just not possible to share details on product plans that are in development. As soon as our product plans are final we will post them here. 

Kylie
Photo of HarrySamuel

HarrySamuel

  • 94 Posts
  • 40 Reply Likes
Same crap, its coming. My VeraPlus arrived today, the light controllers are coming next. Looks so much better than Chamberlain. The light controllers will be here, unlike Chamberlain anything !!!!
Photo of Ethan

Ethan

  • 7 Posts
  • 11 Reply Likes
Kylie, I am NOT asking for products plans.

Does Chamberlian intend to make this situation correct in the future at no additional cost? Yes, or no?

Again, I don't care how it's done.... a firmware update, free hardware update or a refund. Tell me specifics later when you know and can. I'm now done with the benefit of the doubt. You have the ability to answer my question without technical information or a roadmap. You are avoiding it.

Kylie, you're trying. Please get us an an executive from the MyQ management team with the power to answer questions.
(Edited)
Photo of Max Curtis

Max Curtis

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Well hello Kylie, I am happy for you and your new position.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Thanks, Max. :)
Photo of Mac

Mac

  • 6 Posts
  • 4 Reply Likes
Hi Kylie. Thanks for the update. I feel for you. I know you are just the messenger, so please pass this message on to management.
I bought this MyQ product BASED on its widely advertised homekit compatibility. I will never buy another chamberlain product based on the this experience: unfulfilled promises (i.e. lies) and the constant delay tactic. If it really was a priority more resources would have been directed to the project.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
ditto
Photo of Richard Cueto

Richard Cueto

  • 3 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
Just a thought, maybe we should contact Apple and let them know about the deceptive marketing practices going on using their registered 'HomeKit' name.  Maybe their legal will have Chamberlain remove it...
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Apple doesn't care either. I contacted them before I purchased and they stated it was HomeKit compatible. I pointed out the confusion and Chamberlain's waffling and Apple repeatedly assured me it was HomeKit compatible. Nope. And it's confusing how it's listed on their site, linked from their HomeKit compatibility link. Both company's are at fault. No one gives a crap and we consumers are out money.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
ditto
Photo of Ethan

Ethan

  • 7 Posts
  • 11 Reply Likes
A few things... Several credible Mac sites have reported this weekend that iOS 10 (with screenshots) will have it's own dedicated Apple Made "Home" App for HomeKit devices. Given the  leaked info, I have a better understanding of the delays. I see a strong correlation in the development process with the irrigation company who stated that their device has the hardware, but currently is not HomeKit compatible. For those uninformed, HomeKit devices also require apps that support the protocol. It is reasonable to think that Chamberlain knew this and is reallocating their resources, time and dev team accordingly for this iOS release. I have no doubt Chamberlain will release great products in the future. But at what cost to those that invested?

That said, a gentleman hit the nail on the head in the January post about dedicated HomeKit support. He referenced Apple's core DNA. The customer does not know what they want until you show them the device. Surveys, lengthy back and forth is great with a company that listens after they've started to deliver.  

Chamberlain is playing catchup and management must be confident in their monopoly. That's fine. Products like Garagio look like interesting alternatives and I'm waiting to see if they add HomeKit. Remember, MySpace and AOL were there first. Twitter is learning the hard way now. It's not about being first. It's about doing things the correct way. Hubris kills.

Kylie, I'll leave you with a message for management. Steve Jobs had a famous rant after the failed initial launch of MobileMe, which is the predecessor to iCloud. It crashed on launch and took a week to get running correctly and many users lost contact/calendar info and were angry... Jobs brought the entire product team into a Town Hall Meeting... "What the is the product was supposed to do?" When Jobs got a satisfactory answer, he replied "Then why doesn't  it do it?" then proceeded to fire the product's entire management team in front of everyone while naming their replacements. He also made sure the user base was given free services to make up for the failure. If I was running Chamberlain, I'd be doing the same right now.

Best of luck to you, Kylie. Again, I understand how hard this job must be for you and I empathize with your situation. It's clear that management doesn't care, or is incompetent based on my follow up questions. It must be awful to be their lightning rod. I commend your effort.

I'd still advise your management team to take a proactive stance and talk directly to us, even if there is no future product/roadmap info given.  You can gain a lot of PR points back by letting us know if we will be offered free upgrades at some point or our money back. I've been patient for a year and can wait. I just want to know I didn't waste my money. I'm sure others feel the same way.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
great post, but Chamberlain does not care about angering customers, we are the stupid suckers who were so dumb we bought their products. So spend a few minutes and post all over the internet how stupid we were. As they say fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me. Homekit, smartthings, they want a closed system, and even just blocked Smartthings which was working, but now does not. NEVER CHAMBERLAIN AGAIN !!!!!!!!!!
Photo of Matthew Harkins

Matthew Harkins

  • 5 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Hmmmm I might have to return our 2 new openers from Lowes and go a different route after reading all this info. Any other options anyone recommend?
(Edited)
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
I would check with Lowes if they have a brand that works with their IRIS controller, or a z-wave system. Chamberlain has been playing games for a very long time. Return it while you can !!!
Photo of Jon McCullough

Jon McCullough

  • 20 Posts
  • 6 Reply Likes
This is fascinating and perhaps related.  Perhaps not.  Either way hope may come, right?

http://www.techhive.com/article/3067368/internet-of-things/apple-homekit-may-get-an-official-control...
Photo of John Jones

John Jones

  • 4 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
If the gateway, i.e. the hardware chamberlain sells was HomeKit compatible it would work with all sorts of applications and be secure 

sort it out and get it done ASAP forget about your custom app until this is done...
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi everyone, 

A little update...I met with one of our executives for about 45 minutes today. We discussed our MyQ Community and all of the great requests that you all have been bringing up. He gave me some updates on where we're at with several of our initiatives and I feel comfortable saying that it's going to be a great year for MyQ and I think we're heading in the right direction. I can't relay those details to you just yet, but I wanted you all to know that I haven't forgotten about you and that I've made sure the right people got the message just like I promised.

Thanks for staying passionate guys! Keep up the good dialog. People like you are the forward thinkers that we need to hear from in order to drive positive change and fuel great ideas for our products.

Stay awesome, 

Kylie :) 
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Wasn't last year when Homekit support was announced supposed to also be a good year? Why should we believe this update now?
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
WOW, they are listening and everything will be fine tomorrow, yes, tomorrow, its just a day away. Wait is this not what we have been told over and over and over ?? Tomorrow, tomorrow, tomorrow, its just a day away. deja vu I've been here before! I know I have, I am sure I have been here before. I guess that's their story and they are sticking to it. And as Bill Clinton said "I did not have sex with that woman". Wonder when I can look back and laugh. Well actually I am already laughing.
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Thanks Kylie for the update. It is a little light on details so we are going to have to be patient and hope for the best.

I'd encourage those that need something sooner (either because of having less patience or more frustration) do their research and find something that works for them. Hopefully you have realized that the platform matters. Look for something extensible. Ideally, the devices you select should be inter-operable and work with things like IFTTT, Amazon Alexa, Wink, and HomeKit. I've been successful with the ecobee3 thermostat, Lutron Caseta light switches, iHome iSP5 smart plugs, and an Amazon Echo Dot.

I'd also encourage us to not over-complicate the solution. For example, the Honeywell Econoswitch RPLS740B works great for both indoor and outdoor lights that turn on at sunset and off at a desired time or sunrise. I have several of these that I've set up once and have never had to mess with again.

To those who are still posting just to complain (you know who you are), please stop.

Best,
Jeffrey
Photo of cen3

cen3

  • 4 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
The REAL question we all need to ask ourselves is, do we REALLY trust these folks to provide the unlock capability (from anywhere) of our homes? ....I don't know about the rest of you but the garage door in my house is a pretty important entry to the house and based on everything I've seen, I DO NOT trust that the folks at Chamberlain take this serious enough to provide us with real home security.

They don't seem to care passionately about the hardware and software driving it and I don't think they'd adequately secure my home while I'm sleeping or while i'm away.

Based on how slow they move can any of you imagine how long it could take them to respond to something like a network intrusion where a hacker sits on their network opening our doors while providing access for thieves to walk right in - it could be catastrophic, putting our health and safety at risk. 

That aside, the fact this product has been on the market for so long without the promised functionality calls for a class-action lawsuit and I'm surprised nobody has put that together. - Best I can figure Chamberlain hasn't "pushed the red button" saying the current hardware won't work (so who knows what happens if that day comes)  but I think at this juncture we can at least assure ourselves that the folks at this company don't take this "Smart Home" stuff (nor us as customers) seriously and as a result they will likely NEVER GET IT RIGHT (to our standards).

We should be looking towards something like a Kickstarter project to do this - if anyone finds anything like that please let me know, i'll fund it instantly just to see someone eat into Chamberlain's market-share.
(Edited)
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
cen3,

I think you may have that backward. I wonder if the reason why they haven't added the functionality as desired is because they want to make sure it is secure, bullet proof in fact. Maybe high standards are keeping the updates from being released. How secure are actions triggered via IFTTT? Do I really trust an action from IFTTT to open my garage door?

I don't trust a Kickstarter project to get to market any sooner. Today, Garageio has support for both IFTTT and Amazon Alexa (SmartThings coming) but not support for HomeKit.

Jeffrey
Photo of cen3

cen3

  • 4 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
Well, i'm not sure what you do for a living but I just put down my code to respond to this because let me assure you that it would not take 1 person several years to make the software - I do this for a living so I can speak intelligently on the matter. - The issue is they don't have anyone in that company that knows what they're doing - this isn't rocket science. Several other (lesser funded) companies have figured it out so think about that one for a bit. - The reason they're dorking around on this matter is the Homekit spec requires a chip that can do 3,072-bit keys, and Curve25519 elliptic curve crypto (https://developer.apple.com/homekit/)  - anyone willing to open up their device and throw some high-res pictures of the front and back of the board in there I'll do the research and see if they're capable of meeting those specs... I'm guessing they won't be but we can get to the bottom of it at least and know.

As far as a kickstarter campaign I'll give you that - these don't pop up overnight but between Indegogo and Kickstarter it's just a matter of time before some group of kids says, hey we can solve this easier, faster, better and cheaper - don't think for one minute that just because Chamberlain is making Garage Door openers that they have some high-tech lab where they have Google level engineers - keep this in the context of what is considered complex in 2016 - we have drones, robots and self driving cars and trucks about to be commonplace - hell you can already get a Tesla that parks itself (as long as you don't do it near any big tractor-trailer trucks) - and it's absurd to think that there's some grand mystical problem to be solved here - I've been a software developer for 25+ years and I can assure you these folks are not apply the proper resources, funding and team to solve this matter - plain and simple.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Cen3,

Jeffery said it well. We make security our top priority. I encourage you to read my open letter to the community above. You will find more information about our development and review process that touches on the topics you mentioned. 

Kylie 
Photo of cen3

cen3

  • 4 Posts
  • 2 Reply Likes
Yes I saw and read the well crafted letter that your attorney's (or at least CEO) had to okay before it went out to ensure it dangled the carrot just right as to not open up any additional points of liability while trying to satisfy those customers that are irate over the lack of prioritization this division of the company has been given.

Just by looking at your Job Openings in the company (http://www.chamberlaingroup.com/corporate/en-us/assets/jobPostings/JDDeveloperiOSMobileApplication.d...) it's pretty obvious that you guys are needing someone to interface with your outside developers. The fact this job remains unfilled does not give me confidence that you guys can even attract the right talent or know how to build a competent team that can advance this product line.
** Effective Date, May 2014... this job has remain unfilled for 2 years, wonder why nothing has happened with the product in same time???

So you're over here talking about how security is paramount and you're not even hiring someone with a background in cryptography - this job is to be filled by someone with a minimum of 5 years doing software dev and 2 years doing mobile. - Let me ASSURE everyone out there, 5 years of development experience is NOTHING when you're talking about the skillset that 1 person would need to do all the level of interfacing they're asking of them.

I'm sorry to blow the lid off this one folks but Chamberlain is woefully unprepared to have a team of experienced and talented security experts here to protect your data which means it'll all be handled by outside partners - so you're further abstracting the level of control of who can open and close the garage door on your home... 

I've said enough - people who are giving these folks so much credit should save their applause for the folks in China who are cranking out the units that keep the lights on in this company and to keep the executives flying private (or at least 1st class) - working out of Elmhurst, Illinois you're going to be hard pressed to find and attract the type of folks who can make stuff happen quickly, lord only knows they're outside developers are probably overseas.
(Edited)
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
WOW, I love it, funny thing is I found guys who have it ALL working, Chamberlain should hire the guys who cracked it without Chamberlain's help.

As I posted so many times before Fred and Barney at Chamberlain are working at it, they have to walk Dino every few minutes, Dino is really old and needs to be walked a lot. And Fred and Barney are old too. They sleep during the day, and at night too, and the trips to the donut shop, well they are taking a C+++ course and then will look at Java. Be patient, it will come soon, no more that 2215, its almost a day away. Tomorrow, tomorrow its coming tomorrow, come sing along, tomorrow, tomorrow, its just a day away.

And all this crap about security, I have windows, (THE GLASS ONES) securing my garage door is really a non-issue. I get an EMAIL and TEXT anytime anything happens in my house. Light goes on in any room, and I get notice, video is next on my list.

I got tired of waiting for Chamberlain to do SOMETHING, ANYTHING !!

Oh did I mention I use a Microsoft phone, ya no Chamberlain APP for it, oh wait I have it,

Thanks to SMART programmers : )
(Edited)
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
John,

If you still have the MyQ as part of your solution, please post the details so others can learn from your experience. If you swapped out everything and went with VeraPlus with z-wave or zigbee compatible devices, don't bother. You didn't do anything clever.

Earlier you said you had things working with both HomeKit and Alexa. Here you say you have a Microsoft phone. Please explain.

Thanks,
Jeffrey
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
I didn't do anything clever, forget my post.
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
John, Thanks for your honesty.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
The guys who use HomeKit, figured it out, and another few guys got Echo working with it. I just found the answers. I just used their work to get it to work, and I use my Microsoft phone. THEY did all the smart stuff. So all my Chamberlain stuff works with all my other stuff, and it all works together.

But I did not do anything clever. It was all done by others. Sorry to imply I did anything clever, I just got it working seamlessly for me. Really like that it ALL integrated so well. Thought I might have to take the Chamberlain stuff out, but no, some really clever guys, much smarter than me did it for me.

Again to be clear I DID NOT DO ANYTHING CLEVER, I just found the solution, any moron can do that. Well Chamberlain hasn't yet, and I guess a few others here haven't, yet. But I am sure they all will, it was easy, well not that easy, well not easy at all, but I am not clever and I got it ALL working.

To be clear ALL my Chamberlain stuff is installed and working with everything else like one seamlessly integrated system. Chamberlain garage door opener, Chamberlain lights, all integrated into all other switches and controllers, Homekit is running for a few guys who helped me, and Echo is working for another set of really CLEVER guys who also helped me, I do not include myself in these groups of clever guys, I am not clever.

I'm just an average guy who has his stuff working.
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
John,

Just to clarify, if you swapped out the whole solution, that isn't clever. Finding alternate solutions and getting pieces working (even if you didn't do it all yourself), can be considered clever by nature of the ingenuity of the authors. See, average guys can be clever when they learn from others.  ;)

Are you using HomeBridge with the Chamberlain MyQ Garage plugin (https://www.npmjs.com/package/homebridge-myq) and the Alexa Skills Kit: Alexa-MyQGarage (https://github.com/jbnunn/Alexa-MyQGarage)? Any chance you are using a Raspberry PI as the HomeBridge server?

Thanks,
Jeffrey
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
Just to be clear, I swapped out NOTHING period, ALL my original Chamberlain products are installed and working, with ALL the controls that Chamberlain is not doing. Glad we are clear on that. I am not clever, just very persistent.
Photo of tsteele93

tsteele93

  • 15 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Did you use the SmartThings code at github or on the SmartThings board? Because according to SmartThings, Chamberlain has asked them to (and they are going to) disable that code because it used an undocumented part of their API and it won't work anymore.

I too had it all working for about three days, when I received notification that it was no longer going to work anymore. I blasted Chamberlain on the Amazon review page (since I had just purchased the MYQ on Amazon.)

That would be my recommendation to those of you who, like me, are disappointed with the combination of lack of HomeKit implementation and the disabling of Amazon Echo functionality. Go to the Amazon page and write a FAIR review detailing your complaints and dislikes and likes about the product. That will get more done than complaining here.
(Edited)
Photo of Jason

Jason

  • 4 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Having grown tired of empty promises and waiting, I did something similar last week.  I installed node.js, homebridge and homebridge-platform-myq (not the homebridge-myq one, as I couldn't get that to work).  Setup forever as a process manager for the homebridge software, dropped my username & password in for the myq package, started it up, and boom, I can say "Open the pod bay doors".

Hilarious that the open source world and average folks can solve a problem in minutes that Chamberlain hasn't been able to solve in months.
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
Yes, you found the answer, I did too, don't post it here Chamberlain might shut it down. They shut down SmartThings, and Echo. Who know what these %$&^ $#@%'s will do.
Photo of Von Alan Cooley

Von Alan Cooley

  • 3 Posts
  • 4 Reply Likes
Open Letter to Chamberlain:

You have it in your power to resolve this issue almost immediately. Simply offer a refund of the purchase price of the MyQ Garage unit to anyone that made the purchase expecting to have Homekit compatibility. Each consumer can then decide if this is something they care about or not. 

In my case I would probably take the offer because there are other GDO automation options that simply work better than what I have experienced with MyQ Garage. Also, since there has been no product improvement in the past year I can only consider this a dead product and that you have been assigned to this community to do damage control.

I can assure you that anyone who asks me will NOT purchase MyQ products based on my experience with MyQ Garage. I am very happy with the GDOs themselves but Chamberlain/Liftmaster has not demonstrated any commitment to the MyQ ecosystem.
Photo of Greg Takacs

Greg Takacs

  • 5 Posts
  • 9 Reply Likes
No offense, but simple multi user authentication and device specific user access and time access has nothing to do with car manufacturers or ever changing technological landscape. It's a copout for not even getting the most basic of the basics right from the get go. You had, literally, years to get something so simple as this working and you have failed to do so. It is simply unacceptable. Had my builder not bought 4 myQ ready openers for my house I'd be looking at something else myself.
(Edited)
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
search google, find an answer, don't waste time here good luck
Photo of John Jones

John Jones

  • 4 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
any update ? will we see anything at apple WWDC ?

thanks

John 
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
Hi there MyQ Community. 

Unfortunately, I can't share any updates at the moment.

However, I encourage everyone to make sure their profile information (name, email, username, etc.) is up-to-date over the few days. ;)

Best,

Kylie
Photo of Jon McCullough

Jon McCullough

  • 20 Posts
  • 6 Reply Likes
Roger will do!  Thank you again from an anxious and appreciative customer!
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Anything less than HomeKit support is available this week as a firmware update is unacceptable.
Photo of Seth Goldberg

Seth Goldberg

  • 3 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
Ignore the whiners. Looking forward to your announcements!
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
The whinners have been waiting for over a year. So whiners is not really a fair word to use. 

When you were told something over a year ago, you have a valid complaint. And for an official rep to say make sure your email is right and put it in an email is ????

I hope Kyle understands if my email is wrong, I will not get the email to make sure its right. I mean he hopefully understand this. And sending an email about an announcement in a few days only setups up the next disappointment. The it's coming soon is so old.
Photo of jdotinc

jdotinc

  • 6 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Who's Kyle? You've got a back-channel with a guy named "Kyle" at Chamberlain? Strange - we're all looking forward to an update from Kylie (Female).
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
they change names every once in a while. Not sure any of them are real names.
Photo of MyQ Community Manager

MyQ Community Manager

  • 161 Posts
  • 96 Reply Likes
It's indeed my real name. :)
Photo of Jeffrey

Jeffrey

  • 19 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
That is specifically funny coming from someone named John Smith.  ;)
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
It's indeed my real name. :)

Chamberlain has taught me well : )
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
And to sun will come out tomorrow, tomorrow, its just a few days away !
Photo of jdotinc

jdotinc

  • 6 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
At the end of the day, I try to remember that this is a company filled with real people - who deserve some respect. I can't speak to the series of decisions/problems/mistakes, etc... that have lead to this point - but let's not let something that is, all things considered, relatively minor (I want Siri/HomeKit control for my app controlled garage door opener, which does sounds like a pretty 1st-world problem to me), turn us into an angry mob. 

They've promised improved communication, and some updates - I vote that we give them the chance to deliver on that.

HomeKit has proved to be difficult for many vendors - for reasons which we can mostly just speculate. To my knowledge there aren't any garage related productions with HomeKit compatibility on the market today, and I don't think that is a coincidence.

I regularly see comments on forums like this (and Rachio, and August, etc...) where people chime-in with comments implying that it should be "so easy to do X", or "just add Y API to support such-and-such feature". The reality is that developing, shipping, and supporting a cloud-backed piece of hardware isn't easy, and when you consider the security implications of "getting it wrong" as it pertains to something like garage doors - which could allow access to multiple-thousands of dollars in property - or worse, your family, I am fine with them taking the time to get it right.

The MyQ platform certainly has room for improvement, and their marketing may have gotten ahead of their product - which is a mistake I'm sure they'll learn from, but for me - it already solves a big problem, and provides me with a lot of functionality for an extremely fair price. I've got remote control of 2 garage doors, with alerts and auto-close functionality for about $100. Most of my neighbors are shocked when I show them how cool, simple,  and cost-effective this solution is - and the best part, it has yet to give me any problems at all. That is more than I can say for the rest of my home automation hardware, and this is something I've been dabbling with for the last 10+ years (x10, PLM, Insteon, Control4, Z-Wave, SmartThings, HomeKit, etc...).

I hope this all works out for everyone, and I'd certainly love some additional features - but I also know that early adoption of new/emerging tech carries with it a lot of risk (compatibility, stability, false starts, broken promises) - if you want something that "just works" today, HomeKit isn't it - yet.
Photo of Michael Maulucci

Michael Maulucci

  • 13 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
I can't wait for HomeKit to be added, but not for using Siri! So I don't have to hear all this whining and crap from everyone. Is chamberlain going to add HomeKit, who knows, but I think after Apple releases their plans, chamberlain will be able to start giving details. But if they don't, get over it! Lots of things I've bought failed to live up to their promises right away or ever. Sony had promises that they didn't deliver on PS3 and ps4. I don't see everyone sending their systems back and calling for a refund. Your system is working 95% of what you bought. That's pretty good. Do you return a Big Mac because it doesn't look like the picture?

Now hopefully we can get back to news and information when it comes, and not 15 notifications of bickering a day!

End of rant

And thank you Kylie for doing your best to keep us updated with what you are able to say!
Photo of Patrick Farfour

Patrick Farfour

  • 2 Posts
  • 1 Reply Like
Kylie,  watching my email but haven't seen anything yet. Can you give us an idea when we might hear anything? 
Photo of tsteele93

tsteele93

  • 15 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Michael,

If I'm reading you correctly you are saying, "I like it ok and it works for me so you guys should like it too. Why are you all complaining?  I like it fine! Shut up already."

That's great that you are happy with it. We are sorry you have to hear from those of us who bought it hoping it would work with homekit because we were told a couple of years ago that it would work with homekit.

We're sorry that we aren't satisfied with the product because we found a workaround that helped us get the functionality we thought we were getting and then Chamberlain said they were going to shut that functionality down.

I guess our complaints threaten your confidence in your decision, so you must marginalize our complaints so you can feel secure that you bought the right thing.

That's the only reason I can come up with for why a consumer would belittle his fellow purchasers of a product for their issues with the product not living up to the promises the company made about that product to the buyers.
Photo of Michael Maulucci

Michael Maulucci

  • 13 Posts
  • 7 Reply Likes
Hi, I am not trying to belittle you or any user. I like constructive criticism and think that is what people need to be talking to and giving to chamberlain. I understand that people would like this feature that was told they will get.

The people I'm talking about not wanting to hear, are not approching the forum with respect or even with understanding of the process. If people would say they are disappointed, but not call names, not fight or argue(without knowing the facts), then I would be ok with reading all the criticism.

But if you look through the threads you will see that is not the case. We may have some really intelligent people on here saying and typing some unintelligent comments.

Kylie has stated what she can, and working with big companies before with nda's she is doing a good job with what she has.

They say that it is coming(just like Apple has said about HomeKit in general) but as everyone knows HomeKit is a slow process. We can hold on to the fact that they said it's coming and are working on it. And yes we can be upset if they come back and say that it will never come.

And you can't blame them for fixing / removing the loophole in using homebridge. Just like any company (Apple, Microsoft, Sony, Google, android) if they find something g that is not authorized, they need to fix it as they can't support it, and are protecting them self.

Again I'm not trying to belittle you at all and felt, that you were respectful in your reply and I like that :)

I will also say though that I'm am not threatened by your comments or anyone's on here. Just more annoyed at the way they come across. The same way I find my 4 year old annoying when she wont listen and keeps asking the same thing over again
(Edited)
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
Why bother, work around it. I have to stop reading these long comments. Accept Chamberlain can't do what others have. Work around it.
Photo of tsteele93

tsteele93

  • 15 Posts
  • 3 Reply Likes
Thanks Michael,

I apologize if I did come across rudely. I just feel like some of the complainers are dismissed because they look like bad guys beating up on the nice employee. But I feel like they have valid points. I agree, rude behavior won't improve anything though. Thanks for your thoughtful reply.

TS
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Kylie, I haven't seen anything worth looking at. I got some nonsense about joining your beta, which would require me to sign a non-disclosure. I won't do that. I'm not here to test things for you for free. When is my MyQ getting a firmware update to support Homekit? That's all I want to know.

Chamberlain's unprofessional behavior is just exhausting. Can I get a refund, please?
Photo of lac5q

lac5q

  • 2 Posts
  • 0 Reply Likes
I would be more than happy to help test if it advances the development in any way!!!
Photo of John Smith

John Smith

  • 45 Posts
  • 12 Reply Likes
Yes, many got the offer to Beta test, I decide to decline. Why should I change or work on something when my system works PERFECTLY :) I get emails if my GD is opened or closed. My lights turn on when I come home and open my GD door. My Myq lights turn on before sunset, and off at 2am. what is there to fix ????

I do wish Chamberlain had done this when I begged, offered to rewrite the APP, and begged some more. Now they want help, after I fixed it ??? 

I have to stop following this thread, it is pointless.
Photo of Alexander Mull

Alexander Mull

  • 1 Post
  • 0 Reply Likes
I check these board a couple times a week to see is there is any new information regarding HomeKit compatibility, or updates on the progress. I was pleasantly surprised when I saw this post about updating profile information (I had wrongly assumed it would be so that those in the thread would be updated as soon as this announcement was made). So far I have not seen anything in the past month in the form of an announcement or update.

I understand that not everything can be shared with the public, but providing regular updates on progress goes a long way towards easing some of the anger customers may have about the delays. If we were provided maybe weekly updates on product integrations that are being worked on or some issues that have been ironed out, I'm sure there would be a lot less complaining.

That being said, I would also be willing to beta test development as well, hoping that it will lead to an update sooner.
Photo of Noah Archer

Noah Archer

  • 19 Posts
  • 5 Reply Likes
My info has been up to date and I have checked the board often yet still no news after this "little carrot" 5 months ago. Why antagonize people who are already pissed at you? Just to be clear, any news other than a notice of HomeKit support (or conversely finally tucking tail and admiring you'll never support HomeKit) is no news. Adding any new or additional features (thermostat or camera integration for example) before supporting previously promised core functionality only goes to infuriate us that much more!
Photo of Noah Archer

Noah Archer

  • 19 Posts
  • 5 Reply Likes
My info has been up to date and I have checked the board often yet still no news after this "little carrot" 5 months ago. Why antagonize people who are already pissed at you? Just to be clear, any news other than a notice of HomeKit support (or conversely finally tucking tail and admiring you'll never support HomeKit) is no news. Adding any new or additional features (thermostat or camera integration for example) before supporting previously promised core functionality only goes to infuriate us that much more!
Photo of LD

LD

  • 106 Posts
  • 58 Reply Likes
Agreed. Any news that isn't HomeKit integration is just going to piss us off. Telling us you're working on it just pisses us off. Is it available? If the answer is no then don't bother replying.
Photo of katen

katen

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
Apple Watch support today is a great step for the App. Thank you!
Photo of Jorge Eduardo Serrato Pinto

Jorge Eduardo Serrato Pinto

  • 1 Post
  • 1 Reply Like
If Chamberlain does not allow this integration then it is a choice to choose another product if it is integrated. Who can recommend another brand to replace Chamberlain?